Varför den semantiska webben inte kommer att fungera
10 november 2003 | 1 kommentar
En utmärkt artikel av Clay Shirky om svårigheterna med att välordna världen, trots ett aldrig så väl uttänkt schema:
”… Arthur Conan Doyle, whose Sherlock Holmes stories have done more damage to people’s understanding of human intelligence than anyone other than Rene Descartes. Doyle has convinced generations of readers that what seriously smart people do when they think is to arrive at inevitable conclusions by linking antecedent facts. (—)
In the real world, we are usually operating with partial, inconclusive or context-sensitive information. When we have to make a decision based on this information, we guess, extrapolate, intuit, we do what we did last time, we do what we think our friends would do or what Jesus or Joan Jett would have done, we do all of those things and more, but we almost never use actual deductive logic.
As a consequence, almost none of the statements we make, even seemingly obvious ones, are true in the way the Semantic Web needs them to be true.”
Läs hela: The Semantic Web, Syllogism, and Worldview.
Kommentarer
En kommentar to “Varför den semantiska webben inte kommer att fungera”
Kommentera
november 11th, 2003 @ 13:44
Liz Lawley listar några svar på Shirkys artikel:
http://mamamusings.net/archives/2003/11/10/shirky_touches_off_a_storm_of_semantic_web_posts.php